Firearms
Groups say gunshot detection systems unreliable, seek review
Long before latest DC crime lab troubles, some employees raised concerns
Who pulled the trigger? Gun muzzle exhaust may complicate analysis of crime scenes
Allegations Against DC Crime Lab Potentially Put Prosecutions in Jeopardy
National forensics board suspends D.C. crime lab’s accreditation, halting analysis of evidence, city says
Ballistics work at D.C.’s crime lab criticized by forensic experts
DC forensic lab under criminal investigation over firearms case
Mock Juror Perceptions of Forensics
Speakers: Brandon Garrett, Nicholas Scurich, and William Crozier. Presented by CSAFE. Recording available.
United States v. Tibbs, 2016-CF1-19431.
After applying the Daubert factors, the court reached the conclusion that ballistic matching lacks the scientific integrity to make statements of certainty. The court limited the ballistics expert testimony to only stating that the gun could not be excluded as a potential source of the bullet.
Missouri v. Goodwin-Bey, No. 1531-CR00555-01 (Cir. Ct. Green County, Mo., Dec. 16, 2016).
The court allows the ballistics expert testimony, but limits the testimony to say that the gun in question could not be eliminated as a source of the bullet.
Missouri v. Goodwin-Bey, No. 1531-CR00555-01 (Cir. Ct. Green County, Mo., Dec. 16, 2016).Read More
Williams v. United States, 130 A.3d 343 (D.C. 2016).
The court affirmed the admissibility of the Government’s expert witness’s statement of certainty concerning the ballistic evidence. The expert testified that the markings were, “unique to that gun, and that gun only.” Id. at 346. Due to a failure to object by the defense and a lack of binding law that says otherwise, the inclusion …
Williams v. United States, 130 A.3d 343 (D.C. 2016).Read More
United States v. Taylor, 663 F. Supp. 2d 1170 (D.N.M. 2009).
The court finds that ballistics science is admissible, and notes the level of subjectivity and the impossibility of a perfect match in this field of science. The court prohibits the expert testimony from saying that the ballistic match is to a scientific, practical, or absolute certainty to exclude all other firearms.
United States v. Taylor, 663 F. Supp. 2d 1170 (D.N.M. 2009).Read More
United States v. Glynn, 578 F. Supp. 2d 567 (S.D.N.Y. 2008).
The court finds that ballistics examination lacks the rigor and certainty of other forensic sciences, and there a limit is needed on the degree of confidence given during testimony. The court limits testimony to “more likely than not”.
United States v. Glynn, 578 F. Supp. 2d 567 (S.D.N.Y. 2008).Read More
United States v. Alls, No. 2:08-cr-00223-ALM (S.D. Ohio Dec. 7, 2009).
Defendant filed a motion to exclude expert testimony which was denied in part and granted in part. The court held that the expert could provide testimony concerning toolmark evidence, but could not testify that a match was found to a degree of certainty which excludes all other firearms in the world from being the source.
United States v. Alls, No. 2:08-cr-00223-ALM (S.D. Ohio Dec. 7, 2009).Read More
