Reports and Publications
by John Louis Larsen and Daniel K. Harris, The Champion (NACDL) 28-35 (October 2011). A guide for defense attorneys for assessing whether law enforcement followed standardized evidence processing and collection guidelines, as per those promulgated by the FBI and DOJ.
Developed by the National Forensic Science Technology Center and is available for free download.
U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice. A guide designed to accompany the general crime scene guide. Provides step-by-step procedures for each phase of crime scene investigation. Provides more specific procedures than the general guide does for some topics.
U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice. A best-practices guide for death scene investigators produced by the National Medicolegal Review Panel, an independent multidisciplinary group of both international and national organizations whose constituents are responsible for investigating death.
by John Louis Larsen, 8 Evidence Tech. Mag. 14-17 (July-August 2010). Provides protocols for documenting a bullet-hole entry and for event reconstruction.
2013 NIST handbook offers guidance for individuals involved in the collection, examination, tracking, packaging, storing and disposition of biological evidence
U.S. Department of Justice, FBI Laboratory Division. Provides guidance and procedures for methods of collecting, preserving, packaging, and shipping evidence and describes the forensic examinations performed by the FBI’s Laboratory Division and Operational Technology Division.
From the Blog
- Paul Bieber (Director at Arson Research Project: http://thearsonproject.org/research/) explores the misidentification of an accidental fire as an act of arson and how unreliable, quasi-scientific techniques led to the mistaken execution of an innocent man. On June 30th, join the UNC School of Government and the North Carolina Office of Indigent Defense Services for the seventh …
- New Research on “Touch” DNA, 1/6/2016As the sensitivity of DNA analysis increases, scientists are able to develop profiles from ever-smaller samples of DNA. This has lead to testing of a wider array of samples collected from crime scenes, including window panes, bullets, hats and other clothing, cigarette butts, and many other items. Attorneys sometimes ask me about the likelihood of …
- FRONTLINE: The Real CSI, 4/5/2012Mark your calendars: on April 17, 2012, FRONTLINE reports on serious flaws in forensic practices and inconsistencies in how forensic evidence is presented in the courtroom. The program will be broadcast on PBS stations and online. FRONTLINE investigates reliability of fingerprint analysis, ballistics, and bite mark analysis and evaluates the standards that govern these practices. …
- Crime Scene Investigation – New Website, 1/12/2012As a follow-up to my post from earlier this week on crime scene investigation, I have created a website with articles and publications that describe best practices for physical evidence recognition, evidence preservation and collection, and crime scene documentation. I have posted standards and guidelines for crime scene investigation and other crime scene resources on …
- Crime scene forensics: How does it work?, 1/10/2012BBC News has posted a series of videos explaining how forensic tests are performed in crime labs on their Crime scene forensics: How does it work website. These short videos demonstrate various techniques including fingerprint comparisons, use of ninhydrin and superglue fuming (cyanoacrylate) to locate latent print evidence, firearm and projectile comparisons, and examination of …
NCAJ Webinar on crime scene investigation and serology evidence by Marilyn Miller.
The National Forensic Science Technology Center created this website to explain in simplified terms the principles of each type of forensic analysis and how the analysis is performed. Topics include DNA, digital evidence, fingerprints, firearms, trace evidence, blood stains, and more.
BBC News has posted a series of narrated images that describe various crime scene investigation techniques and laboratory tests.
Felony death by vehicle case where the trooper accident reconstruction expert who analyzed the accident could not reach a conclusive expert opinion about who was driving. An officer provided lay opinion testimony based on the same information. The court concluded: “the facts about the accident and measurements available were simply not sufficient to support an expert opinion — as Trooper Souther testified — and lay opinion testimony on this issue is not admissible under Rule 701.” The court found the error was prejudicial and ordered a new trial.
A School of Government blog post on this case is available here.
Motions and Briefs
Federal court order granting relief in the George Goode case. The Court found that “the State, through Agent Deaver, presented misleading evidence about the testing done on petitioner’s boots being conclusive for the presence of blood.” See p. 25-26.
Suit against five former agents with the State Bureau of Investigation, filed on June 28, 2011
2012 Supplement to MAR that addresses implications of false and misleading testimony by former SBI Agent Duane Deaver.
MAR in Michael Peterson case based on newly discovered evidence regarding Duane Deaver and the SBI
- Order – Judge Orlando Hudson’s May 9, 2012 order granting the motion for appropriate relief, vacating the conviction and granting a new trial.
- A copy of the written exhibits from Dec. 2011 hearing, including an index of exhibits can be requested from Sarah Rackley Olson.
- Motion for Relief from Judgment The basis of this Rule 60(b) motion drafted by Diane Savage is misconduct by the SBI Lab.
- AG’s Response to Petitioner’s Rule 60(b)Motion for Relief
- Reply to Respondent’s Memorandum Opposing Motion for Relief
Crime Scene Investigation in the News
- Convicted Darien killer claims false Henry Lee testimony sent him to prison, by Tara O'Neill, Stamford Advocate, 7/11/2019
- Judge Orders New Hearing in 1994 Murder, by Bobby Burns, Reflector, 6/12/2019
- 10 Years Later, Independence Should Be the Future of Forensics, by Jonathan Griner, Forensic Magazine, 6/6/2019
- Law enforcement fears NC’s effort to boost hemp industry could essentially legalize marijuana, by Laura Leslie, WRAL, 5/30/2019
- FBI Scientists Studying Wet Vacuum for DNA on Select Surfaces, by Seth Augenstein, Forensic Magazine, 5/16/2019
- Houston CSI Who Used Own Alternate Light Source Missed Evidence, Was Terminated (TX), by Seth Augenstein, Forensic Magazine, 10/27/2018
- Houston crime lab fires investigator after alleged testing policy violation, by Samantha Ketterer, Houston Chronicle, 10/26/2018
- Experts Call for CSI Reform at San Antonio Forensics Event, by Paul Flahive, Texas Public Radio, 8/7/2018